Seemor
Super Nice PizzaAMust Try
975 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.8/5 Google (146 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout
Creative neighborhood pizzeria with standout crust, strong cocktails, and bakery-level desserts; prices are premium and portions skew personal-sized.
Why it gets an A for overall quality
Super Nice Pizza exemplifies grade A standards through exceptional food quality marked by inventive, produce-driven pies and outstanding service attentiveness with genuine owner presence. Solid consistency and exceptional customer loyalty confirm this neighborhood destination delivers on its promise, though minor pacing concerns during peak hours prevent perfect execution.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling with exposed brick, candlelit touches, and a friendly team that checks in without hovering. A guest summed it up: "Neighborhood vibe with downtown polish." Expect bar chatter, proper glassware, and owner-present hospitality that makes celebrations feel easy. The cooking leans creative and produce-driven rather than red-sauce nostalgia. Think clam pies with bright garlic, smoky potato with herbs, and a burger that rivals dedicated spots. Brunch brings fluffy pancakes and a breakfast pizza; cocktails are thoughtfully mixed and the wine list feels curated, not generic. Families fit right in. Staff are genuinely accommodating to kids, and the menu has sure bets like pepperoni pizza, fries, and pancakes. Portions skew personal-sized for pies but desserts are giant, so sharing a chocolate cake slice makes for a kid-pleasing finish.
At a Glance
- Outstanding crust and inventive pies beyond the usual
- Strong cocktails and curated wines for a full night out
- Welcoming to families and repeat neighborhood visits
- Personal-size pizzas and premium pricing surprise some diners
- Occasional slow drinks or service pacing when busy
What Sets It Apart
- bakery-caliber desserts next door
- creative pizza program with brunch pies
- owner-led hospitality
What People Love
- Crust with perfect chew and char
- Clam and smoky potato pizzas that feel special
- Bakery-level chocolate cake that is huge
- Staff warmth and owner presence that feels genuine
Points of Concern
- Personal-size pizzas can feel pricey for the area; set expectations
- Service pacing can slip during peak hours, especially at the bar
- Seating can be tight; some reservations seated at the bar when packed
- Review patterns show minor marketing adjacency (owner email share) but overall voices are diverse
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$48-68 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Share two pizzas and one small plate to balance personal pie sizing
- Add a salad (Caesar or fennel) to lighten a pizza-heavy order
- Save room for cake; consider affogato if you want a lighter finish
Perfect For
- Date night with cocktails and shared pies
- Family dinners where desserts seal the deal
- Small-group celebrations that want neighborhood-chic vibes
- Solo bar meal with a pie and a stirred drink
Location Insights
Area: Residential-academic corridor serving locals, families, and students; relaxed but increasingly upscale dining scene.
Safety: Generally safe, active foot traffic, well-lit avenues; typical urban vigilance at night.
Nearby: Near Columbia University, Riverside and Morningside Parks; adjacent bakery; mix of bars, cafes, and shops.
Upper West SideThe Upper West Side features a diverse dining scene ranging from casual cafes to upscale restaurants, catering to a mix of local families, university students, and tourists. The atmosphere is generally relaxed and safe, with a strong community feel and easy access to cultural landmarks.
Morningside HeightsMorningside Heights is a sub-area within the Upper West Side centered around Columbia University, characterized by a youthful and intellectual vibe. Dining options here include affordable eateries, coffee shops, and international cuisine catering to the academic community.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday17:00–22:00
Tuesday17:00–22:00
Wednesday17:00–22:00
Thursday17:00–22:00
Friday17:00–23:00
Saturday10:00–14:00, 17:00–23:00
Sunday10:00–14:00, 17:00–21:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →