Seemor
SupperB+Worth Trying
156 E 2nd St, New York, NY 10009
· Northern Italian restaurant, Cafe, Caterer
· 4.4/5 Google (1281 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Cozy East Village Italian spot with standout lemon pasta, short rib tortelloni, and lively service; cash-only with premium pricing and occasional service/portion inconsistencies.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Supper delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining through strong food quality anchored by signature dishes like lemon pasta and short rib tortelloni, paired with genuinely attentive service. However, inconsistent execution on certain dishes and tight seating that compromises comfort prevent it from reaching grade A territory. The cash-only policy and occasional wine service confusion add friction that keeps this a solid local favorite rather than a destination restaurant.
Restaurant Summary
Supper channels East Village charm with warm, bustling energy, complimentary beans and bread, and a team that many describe as genuinely attentive. One diner shared, "Our server anticipated everything and kept the evening flowing." However, bring cash—the cash-only policy surprises some first-timers. The cooking leans classic and ingredient-driven rather than flashy—the culinary approach is elevated traditional: lemon spaghetti, Sunday short rib tortelloni, and weeknight lasagna anchor a menu of comfort-forward Italian. Portions are solid, wines are better than expected, and desserts like tiramisu tend to land. Families do fine here thanks to familiar pastas and chicken parm, though the space can be tight and lively. Kids who like simple flavors will find options; those who are picky about textures may skip the beans and crusty bread. No kids menu noted, so plan to share straightforward mains.
At a Glance
- Lemon pasta and Sunday short rib tortelloni are consistent crowd-pleasers
- Cozy, lively vibe with friendly servers and solid wines
- Cash-only policy with onsite ATM and possible fees
- Occasional inconsistency on cutlets and pasta execution
- Some guests reported confusing wine service leading to unexpected bottle charges
What Sets It Apart
- daily_risotto_and_suppers
- complimentary_beans_and_bread
- open_kitchen_counter
What People Love
- Bright, memorable lemon spaghetti
- Rich Sunday short rib tortelloni
- Attentive, kind service that feels familial
- Complimentary beans and bread ritual
- Better-than-expected wines by the glass
Points of Concern
- Cash-only can limit ordering; ATM fees reported
- Reports of pushy wine service resulting in bottle charges for some groups
- Veal/chicken cutlets sometimes too thin or overcooked
- Tight seating; counter by stoves can be uncomfortably hot
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$70-88 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Start with Stracciatella Mozzarella ($29.95), then Short Rib Tortelloni ($34.95), finish with tiramisu (price not listed)
- Value path: share one appetizer, choose a pasta main, and a dessert to split
Perfect For
- Date night with comforting Italian classics
- Group celebrations where lively atmosphere helps
- Pasta-focused dinners with strong desserts
- Locals craving dependable weeknight specials
Location Insights
Area: Lively East Village block with bars and indie restaurants; draws date nights, groups, and neighborhood regulars.
Safety: Busy, well-trafficked nightlife area; typical urban awareness advised late night.
Nearby: Near Avenue A/1st Ave bar scene, theaters, and other Frank group venues; strong evening foot traffic.
Lower East SideThe Lower East Side offers a dynamic dining scene with a mix of traditional delis, innovative restaurants, and hip bars. It attracts a diverse crowd looking for authentic ethnic foods, contemporary cuisine, and lively social settings. The area is known for its energetic nightlife and cultural vibrancy.
East VillageThe East Village, adjacent to the Lower East Side, is known for its bohemian vibe, eclectic eateries, and casual dining spots. It has a youthful, artsy atmosphere with many affordable and experimental food venues.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–00:00
Tuesday16:00–00:00
Wednesday16:00–00:00
Thursday16:00–00:00
Friday16:00–01:00
Saturday11:00–01:00
Sunday11:00–00:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →