Coal-oven pies and classic Italian fare deliver crowd-pleasing flavor, but service inconsistency and delivery delays can sour the experience; best enjoyed dine-in for pizza.
Table 87 delivers strong coal-oven pizza quality and a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere that keeps regulars returning, but occasional burnt pies and temperature inconsistencies prevent grade A performance. Service varies noticeably—excellent bar staff offset by delivery delays and front-of-house gaps—making it a reliable choice for dine-in pizza and cocktails rather than a destination establishment.
The front counter hums with slice traffic while the back room opens into a cozier dining space, a scene that feels warm and bustling when busy. Service experiences diverge—some note servers who go above and beyond, others report confusion or long waits. One diner summed up the vibe: "The bar was welcoming and the martini spot-on," even as another cautioned about delayed takeout. Overall, it is a classic neighborhood spot best enjoyed on-site for pies fresh from the coal oven. The kitchen leans classic Italian—coal-oven pizzas with a slightly sweet sauce, hearty pastas, and old-school appetizers—favoring elevated traditional over culinary theatrics. The Margherita, vodka pie, and baked clams draw repeat praise, though a few pies cross from char to burnt when busy. Prices sit above slice-joint territory but align with a full-service pizzeria and bar that highlights quality ingredients. Families fit right in. Pizza, chicken parm, wings, and simple pastas give plenty for kids, and staff have handled birthday groups with care. There is no explicit kids menu, but the core lineup is kid-friendly by nature; just avoid seats too close to the oven on hot days.
Area vibe: Historic, upscale residential with boutique retail; attracts families, professionals, and visitors exploring Brooklyn waterfront.
Safety: Generally safe and well-lit with steady foot traffic; low perceived risk.
What's nearby: Near Brooklyn Bridge Park and Atlantic Ave shops; close to subway lines and Cobble Hill dining.