Seemor
Uptown › Upper West Side › The Milling Room
The Milling RoomC+?
446 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
· New American restaurant
· Upper West Side
Design-forward Upper West Side spot with creative New American cooking and a grand room, but recent reports show inconsistent execution, slow service, and sporadic pop-up style menus.
Our take
⚠️ Review concerns: This assessment reflects moderate uncertainty due to questionable review patterns. See details in Authenticity Assessment. The Milling Room delivers an exceptional dining room with skylit elegance and comfortable spacing, but inconsistent food quality and unreliable service pacing undermine the experience.
One caveat: Service delays for drinks and entrees reported on multiple recent visits
Standout dishes
- Dry-aged NY strip
- Pappardelle carbonara
- Lobster ravioli
What people love
- The soaring, skylit space that feels special
- Bar happy hour value with strong cocktails
- Classic mains like the steak when well executed
Opening Hours
Monday
Tuesday16:30–21:30
Wednesday16:30–21:30
Thursday16:30–21:30
Friday16:30–21:30
Saturday16:30–21:30
Sunday
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →