Creative Modern Mexican with standout ceviches, tacos, and margaritas; strong bar program and lively vibe, but small portions and service inconsistencies at peak times.
Toloache delivers exceptional food quality with inventive ceviches, polished tacos, and creative seafood preparations that justify its reputation as a neighborhood favorite on the Upper East Side. Strong service attentiveness and knowledgeable bartenders elevate the experience, though occasional consistency variations and small portions relative to pricing prevent advancement to grade A territory. The cozy, lively setting appeals to locals and museum-goers but lacks the distinctive destination factor that defines higher-tier establishments.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely expensive ($25+ mains, premium steaks $60+) which may surprise casual diners