Upscale, creative Mexican near Broadway with standout guac, ceviches, and cocktails; crowded room and service pace vary, portions run small for the price.
Toloache delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality—fresh guacamole, balanced ceviches, and impressive short rib—paired with an excellent cocktail program and prime Midtown theater location. However, inconsistent execution across visits and cramped seating prevent grade A territory. Worth visiting for pre-show cocktails and contemporary Mexican fare, though portions run modest for the price point.
One caveat: Service pacing varies: some waits and rushed check drops at peak