Welcoming neighborhood Greek cafe with standout hospitality, broad brunch-to-dinner menu, fair prices, and occasional service missteps; great for locals, families, and casual meetups.
Underhill Cafe Brooklyn delivers exceptional food quality anchored by fresh Greek classics and solid brunch execution, paired with outstanding service warmth from an engaged owner and staff. Consistent execution and strong customer loyalty reinforce its standing as a respected neighborhood favorite, though the modest setting appeal and occasional isolated service gaps prevent it from reaching grade A territory.
One caveat: One report of missing aioli on lamb burger and no notice before serving