Casual Greek spot for flavorful gyros, bowls, and platters with strong fan following; expect counter service, fair prices, and occasional inconsistency on portions and doneness.
Efi's Gyro delivers solid food quality with flavorful gyros and house-made sauces that earn strong local loyalty, but inconsistent execution on protein doneness and portions prevents higher standing. The casual counter-service model and limited seating work for quick neighborhood visits, though occasional order mix-ups and variable staff knowledge create friction. Fair pricing and a strong regular following make it a reliable choice for straightforward Greek comfort in downtown Montclair.
On Bloomfield Ave, Efi's Gyro runs on a fast-casual rhythm: order at the counter, snag a seat, and watch a steady stream of pickups. The vibe is lively and casual with delivery drivers coming and going, and fans praising friendly staff. One diner summed it up: "Hot, fresh gyro and ready right when they said." Seating is limited inside, but there is some sidewalk seating for people-watching. The cooking skews classic Greek street food: gyros, souvlaki, bowls, and platters with house tzatziki and the signature Efi sauce. When it clicks, flavors are bold and satisfying—juicy meats, soft pita, fries tucked inside. Critics point to inconsistency: occasional overcooked chicken or tough lamb and bowls that feel light on meat. Overall, it fits diners looking for straightforward Greek comfort over showy innovation. Families do well here. The menu includes a simple kids menu plus easy wins like chicken gyros, fries, rice bowls, and rice pudding. Portions generally work for sharing, though meat-to-fries balance can vary. If you have picky eaters, lean into chicken gyros, Greek salad with feta, or plain rice bowls; adventurous kids might enjoy fries-in-pita and feta fries.
Area vibe: Lively downtown strip with boutiques, cafes, and family traffic; strong takeout and delivery demand.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked area with evening footfall; typical urban nuisances possible.
What's nearby: Near shops and services on Bloomfield Ave; convenient for errands and quick meals; limited curbside parking.