Excellent Sicilian cooking with standout seafood and desserts, but pricing is high and service can be inconsistent; go for refined flavors if you are comfortable with the spend.
Profumi di Sicilia delivers well-executed Sicilian seafood and standout pistachio tiramisu with knowledgeable service and helpful wine guidance, earning its B+ standing. However, quality variation across visits and recent mixed feedback on pacing and value prevent a higher grade, while a reported food-safety concern adds caution. Best suited for Sicilian seafood enthusiasts willing to accept premium pricing and occasional operational inconsistency.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely high for a trattoria-style room; value depends on seafood quality that night