Bustling downtown spot for classic Icelandic specialties and pub comforts; great for trying iconic dishes, but expect queues and ethical objections to certain menu items.
Íslenski Barinn delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by signature Icelandic dishes and exceptional service attentiveness that explains unfamiliar items with genuine warmth. Tight quarters during peak hours and modest design appeal prevent grade A territory, though the cozy pub atmosphere and fair value make it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants.
Set just off Rainbow Street, this cozy pub-restaurant hums with a warm and bustling energy. Servers often explain the more unusual items with easy charm, and plates arrive quickly even when it is busy. As one diner put it, the room feels like a refuge after a cold day, with friendly, efficient service and plenty of local beer to explore. The cooking skews classic Icelandic comfort with hearty, traditional dishes rather than culinary theatrics. Expect lamb shank with beer sauce, creamy fish pie, reindeer burgers, and small plates like puffin or fermented shark for the adventurous. Most guests praise the flavors and portions, though a few note the occasional dry burger or long wait during peak hours. Prices are typical for Reykjavík, and value feels fair given the ingredients and serving sizes. Families do well here: burgers, fish and chips, pancakes, and skyr keep kids happy alongside more daring options for adults. Reviews mention a generous kids fish portion, and the menu includes vegan and gluten-free notations, making it a practical stop for mixed dietary needs.
Area vibe: Lively downtown core popular with tourists and locals; pubs, shops, and sights within short walks.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, with steady foot traffic; typical urban crowds during peak hours.
What's nearby: Near Rainbow Street, museums, and major tour bus stops; nightlife and retail mix.
Signature picks include the slow-braised lamb shank, the creamy fish pie and the reindeer burger, plus puffin and whale small plates for the adventurous
Casual dress, limited reservations and 10–25 minute waits at peak; the menu also lists whale and puffin
A warm, bustling pub with cozy decor and a lively, social bar vibe