Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Beloved spot opposite Hallgrímskirkja for traditional Icelandic plates and rye bread ice cream; prices are high for simple fare, service can be brusque at peaks, but most diners leave happy.
Café Loki delivers solid A-grade performance anchored by strong traditional Icelandic cooking and exceptional church views that justify its destination appeal. However, inconsistent food execution and variable service quality during busy periods prevent it from reaching grade A territory. The experience remains worthwhile for travelers seeking authentic Icelandic staples in a memorable setting, though service reliability and consistency would need strengthening for higher recognition.
Set opposite the soaring Hallgrímskirkja, this cafe buzzes with travelers and curious eaters exploring Icelandic classics. The room feels warm and bustling, especially upstairs where the church fills the windows. Service ranges from kindly explanatory to a bit stretched at peak, but many praise friendly guidance through the more unusual bites. One diner put it simply: "The view and the rye bread ice cream made the stop memorable." The cooking leans firmly traditional—plokkfiskur, lamb soup, steamed cod, smoked trout, and a sampler with dried fish and fermented shark. Expect comforting, homestyle plates rather than cheffy flourishes, with rye bread as a signature thread from savory to dessert. Adventurous tasters enjoy the small hákarl portion for the cultural experience, while those seeking something gentler gravitate to cod or the hearty soup. Prices feel high compared with casual cafes elsewhere, but here you are paying for the location and classic Icelandic staples. Families do fine if they order smartly: pancakes, rye bread ice cream, lamb soup, and cod are the safest bets for kids. There is no explicit kids menu, and fermented items may challenge picky eaters, so steer toward simple, familiar dishes and consider a shared dessert.
Area: Central, tourist-heavy area opposite Hallgrímskirkja; mix of cafes, souvenir shops, and steady foot traffic.
Safety: Well-lit, busy, and generally safe; high pedestrian activity around landmark.
Nearby: Directly across from Hallgrímskirkja; close to shopping streets and tour pickup points.
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →