Scenic lakeside seafood classic with friendly service and broad menu; food quality is usually good but can be inconsistent and there is a 4% surcharge.
Anthony's Fish Grotto delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by exceptional lakeside setting appeal and attentive, friendly service. However, inconsistent food execution—with reports of bland seasoning and overcooking alongside fresh, satisfying meals—prevents a higher grade. The restaurant excels as a casual family destination with reliable classics like chowder and fish and chips, but lacks the culinary consistency or distinction to compete with the area's premier dining establishments.
Set beside a small lagoon, Anthony’s feels like a hidden lakeside retreat with twinkle lights, ducks, and the hum of conversation. Guests praise friendly servers and relaxing views; one diner shared, "Dinner by the water made the night feel special." A few diners note waits for checks or slower peak-time pacing, but most describe an easygoing, welcoming vibe. The kitchen focuses on classic American seafood—chowder, fish and chips, grilled salmon—peppered with light global touches like miso-glazed fish and octopus tacos. When the kitchen is on, flavors are fresh and satisfying; some recent notes mention bland seasoning or overcooking, so expectations should lean toward comforting standards more than culinary fireworks. Prices track the setting and portions, with a posted 4% surcharge that adds a bit to the bill. Families do well here thanks to a broad menu of kid-friendly staples: fish and chips, burgers, chowder, and simple pastas. The ducks and patio views keep younger diners engaged, though there is no explicit kids menu in sight. If you have picky eaters, stick to fried seafood, chowder, or the burger; adventurous options exist, but classic plates are the safer bet.
Area vibe: Suburban spot by a man-made lake, relaxed crowd, families, date nights, and longtime locals.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit dining enclave with steady foot traffic around the lagoon.
What's nearby: Near I-8; adjacent lagoon with ducks, fountains, lawn and bocce; hotels and residential zones nearby.