Destination-grade seafood with creative Cal-coastal touches and strong cocktails; excellent overall but expect premium pricing, occasional service lapses, and a 4% surcharge.
The Fishery delivers exceptional seafood quality with creative Cal-coastal execution and standout cocktail and service knowledge, positioning it among San Diego's respected seafood destinations. However, inconsistent execution with occasional oversalting and portion variation prevents grade A territory, while service speed lapses and modest design appeal keep it solidly A-grade rather than exceptional. Strong local loyalty and upward momentum reflect reliable neighborhood dining with genuine quality.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely high (mains often $36-$48) and a 4% surcharge applies