Beloved for airy focaccia pizza and casual vibes, now blending Italian classics with Peruvian items; great slices and rotisserie chicken, though service lapses and concept shift divide regulars.
Casa Barotti delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality anchored by exceptional focaccia pizza, but inconsistent execution on newer items and occasional service lapses prevent a higher grade. The Italian-Peruvian fusion concept adds variety and appeals to families seeking casual, affordable dining on College Ave, though the ownership transition has created mixed reactions among longtime regulars about menu direction and consistency.
One caveat: Aperitivo execution is inconsistent; some guests report it never arrived