Bustling New American spot in Belden Place with standout $1 oysters, strong hospitality, and good cocktails, but inconsistent pacing and event execution mean best for small parties over large groups.
Toy Soldier delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional service attentiveness and strong food quality anchored by fresh oysters and well-executed seafood. However, inconsistent execution during busy periods and large groups prevents grade A territory, while the charming Belden Place alley setting offers hidden gem appeal without destination-level distinction. Best experienced as a small-party destination rather than for events.
One caveat: Event execution for large parties has repeated timing and portion complaints; small groups fare better