Seemor
Sarasota › Sarasota › Another Broken Egg Cafe
Another Broken Egg CafeB+Worth Trying
140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
· Brunch restaurant, Breakfast restaurant, Lunch restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (2880 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Bustling beach-village brunch spot with creative Southern-leaning plates, friendly staff, and big portions, but waits and timing inconsistencies can frustrate at peak times.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Another Broken Egg Cafe delivers strong food quality with creative Southern brunch classics and generous portions that justify its loyal following in Siesta Key Village. Friendly, attentive service and a charming beachside location elevate the experience, but inconsistent execution during peak hours—with occasional slow service and lukewarm plates—prevents the grade from climbing higher. Best experienced during off-peak times for optimal reliability.
Restaurant Summary
Set in the heart of Siesta Key Village, this cafe hums with lively beach-town energy. Expect a friendly host stand, a shaded patio, and servers who often offer spot-on recommendations. As one diner put it, "The benedicts and beignets made the wait feel worth it," though peak hours can bring crowded, noisy scenes. The kitchen leans Southern comfort with a modern brunch twist: crab cake benedicts, shrimp and grits, bourbon-soaked pancakes, and the occasional jambalaya or crawfish omelette. It is elevated traditional rather than experimental, with big flavors and bigger portions ideal for post-beach appetites. When the room is slammed, timing can slip and plates may arrive less than piping hot, but off-peak meals earn plenty of praise. Families do well here thanks to pancakes and waffles, straightforward eggs, and flexible sides. The menu offers fruit, potatoes, and simple griddled items many kids enjoy. Strollers and larger parties can strain service at rush times, so for a smoother family visit, aim for earlier mornings or weekdays.
At a Glance
- Generous portions and creative Southern-leaning brunch classics
- Friendly, recommendation-forward servers; high owner responsiveness
- Long waits and slow kitchen at peak hours; occasional lukewarm plates
- Host stand and waitlist management can be inconsistent
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- southern_brunch_favorites
- large_portions
- beach_village_location
What People Love
- Hearty benedicts and indulgent pancakes
- Thoughtful server recommendations
- Seasonal cocktails like lemon blueberry mimosas
- Shaded patio in the village
Points of Concern
- Peak-time delays for seating and food; multiple reports of 45–75 minute waits
- Occasional quality slips: overcooked eggs, cold plates, or skimpy sauce
- Host stand prioritization and waitlist handling frustrate some guests
- Pricing is beach-town level; some perceive it as high for breakfast items
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
- Limited options for conservative palates or picky eaters
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-$44 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For lighter fare, choose Skinny or Monterey Omelette and swap to fresh fruit.
- Seafood fans should target Shrimp 'N Grits or Cajun seafood omelettes.
- Kids often gravitate to buttermilk pancakes or Belgian waffle with bacon.
Perfect For
- Post-beach brunch with hearty portions
- Casual vacation breakfast with cocktails
- Southern-style brunch cravings
- Outdoor patio seating on a sunny day
Location Insights
Area: Touristy beach village with casual shops and bars; heavy weekend and holiday foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe, lively daytime scene; crowding common during peak seasons.
Nearby: Near Siesta Key Beach, boutique retail, other brunch cafes and bars; walkable cluster.
Siesta KeySiesta Key offers a laid-back, beach town dining environment with a mix of casual cafes, seafood restaurants, and bars. The area attracts visitors looking for ocean views and a relaxed social scene, especially during the winter months when seasonal residents arrive.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–14:00
Tuesday07:00–14:00
Wednesday07:00–14:00
Thursday07:00–14:00
Friday07:00–14:00
Saturday07:00–14:00
Sunday07:00–14:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →