Seemor
Sarasota › Sarasota › Demetrio's Restaurant & Pizza
Demetrio's Restaurant & PizzaB+Worth Trying
4410 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34231
· Pizza restaurant, Greek restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (1096 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Old-school Greek-Italian spot for crisp thin-crust pizza, Greek salads, and hearty pastas at friendly prices; service and delivery issues appear inconsistently.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Demetrio's delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong thin-crust pizza and Greek salads and friendly, attentive service that justify its four-decade local following. However, uneven baking and occasional bland nights prevent higher marks, and recent delivery complaints suggest operational friction beyond the core dine-in experience. For families seeking reliable, affordable comfort food in a casual setting, it's a dependable choice—just expect variable execution rather than consistent excellence.
Restaurant Summary
Demetrio's feels like a Sarasota time capsule where families gather over thin-crust pizza and generous Greek salads. Servers are often described as friendly and attentive, and regulars talk about returning for decades. Some diners note uneven experiences, especially around delivery and order issues, so dine-in seems more reliable. The cooking is firmly in the comfort zone: Greek classics, hearty pastas, and old-school pies rather than chefly experiments. Portions run large and prices kind, which explains the loyal crowd. When the oven is hitting right, that crisp bottom and balanced toppings win fans; a few nights show inconsistent bakes or milder flavors. For families, this is an easy yes. Kids can share pizza, pasta, or a half portion on request, and the menu lists plain noodles, simple sauces, and familiar sides. There is no formal kids menu listed, but the team often accommodates straightforward tweaks.
At a Glance
- Thin-crust pizza and Greek salad are frequent crowd-pleasers
- Prices are wallet-friendly with large portions
- Delivery and third-party order problems with finger-pointing on refunds
- Occasional underbaked or bland pies reported on off nights
- Long-time local following and reliable family vibe
What Sets It Apart
- thin_crust_legacy_pizza
- greek_italian_dual_menu
- decades_long_local_following
What People Love
- Nostalgic, unchanged pizza style
- Generous portions at fair prices
- Friendly, efficient servers on good nights
- Greek-Italian menu breadth for mixed groups
Points of Concern
- Delivery disputes handled via third-party apps, limited direct resolution
- Inconsistent baking on some pizzas leading to doughy bottoms
- A few reports of rude service contrasted with many positive ones
- Review patterns show mixed service experiences and some polarized feedback; dine-in consistency appears stronger than delivery
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$24-$38 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair a Greek salad with a small pizza for value
- Choose baked pastas if you want a heartier, forgiving option
- Confirm modifications by phone for takeout accuracy
Perfect For
- Casual family dinners without breaking the bank
- Nostalgic locals craving old-school thin-crust pizza
- Group meals where portions matter
- Quick, comfortable weeknight dine-in
Location Insights
Area: Auto-centric commercial corridor with local shops and eateries; casual, family-oriented traffic and steady daytime flow.
Safety: Generally safe, well-traveled arterial road; typical lighting and foot traffic for suburban strip corridors.
Nearby: Near retail plazas, service businesses, and other casual restaurants along US-41; convenient from residential neighborhoods.
SouthsideSouthside is a primarily residential neighborhood with a variety of local businesses and dining options catering to everyday community needs. The dining scene here is casual and family-oriented, with many affordable and traditional eateries serving local residents and visitors alike.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–20:30
Tuesday11:00–20:30
Wednesday11:00–20:30
Thursday11:00–20:30
Friday11:00–21:00
Saturday11:00–21:00
Sunday11:00–20:30
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →