A popular, traditional Italian restaurant with notably good food and warm hospitality, but advance booking is strongly advisable and service can occasionally be slow.
Tuscany Too delivers strong food quality with consistently praised pasta, pizza, and seafood that showcase freshness and precision, supported by warm, attentive service that keeps diners returning. The bistro-style setting provides genuine appeal without reaching landmark status, and solid execution across dimensions prevents a higher grade from being within reach.
Tuscany Too presents itself as a busy, warmly traditional Italian restaurant on Filey Road, with an inviting interior and a romantic, old-school feel. Guests describe being greeted warmly, finding the room full, and still receiving thoughtful attention; one returning diner particularly valued the staff’s willingness to move the table outdoors. Book ahead: several visitors say prime evenings fill quickly. The cooking is classic rather than experimental, with pasta, pizza, seafood and steaks doing the heavy lifting. Lobster ravioli, al dente pasta, steak with sauce, cheesecake and pistachio ice cream are the recurring stars, while a few diners found the calzone or tiramisu less convincing. It suits date nights, anniversaries and visitors wanting a comforting, traditional Italian meal, with enough range for a mixed group. Families are welcome and reviews specifically praise staff for being kind to children. Pizza, pasta, steak and ice cream offer familiar choices, while vegan adaptation has been reported positively. However, dogs are not accepted except certified assistance dogs, and families should reserve in advance rather than rely on a walk-in table.
Area vibe: Seaside resort town with a mix of tourist attractions, promenades, and residential streets.
Safety: Generally safe in daytime; quieter residential streets at night with limited late-night transport.
What's nearby: Near North Bay and South Bay attractions, seafront, Scarborough railway station and local shops.
Lobster ravioli, steak, and pistachio ice cream are the safest picks, but two classic Italian dishes are less reliable.
Advance booking helps, but you should also allow extra time for service and know that the drinks bill can rise substantially.
Expect a romantic traditional Italian setting that can become busy, with outdoor seating and a welcoming approach to families.