A warmly run Wallingford restaurant that combines generous pizza and pasta with a polished remodel, strong family appeal, and unusually thoughtful event hosting, though occasional delivery and preparation misses warrant ordering carefully.
Olympia Pizza & Spaghetti House II delivers strong food quality and attentive service that keep regulars returning, with pizza, pasta, and specialty dishes earning consistent praise. The remodeled European-inspired setting provides welcoming neighborhood appeal, though operational complexity across delivery, events, and varied menu items prevents a higher grade. Solid execution across the board makes it a reliable local choice rather than a destination standout.
From an unassuming exterior, Olympia opens into a softened, remodeled Wallingford dining room with warm lighting, comfortable seating, and a quietly romantic feel. Reviewers repeatedly describe the owners and staff as welcoming enough to make the place feel personal—one family said it felt more like dinner in someone's home than a routine restaurant visit. Service is a standout across dine-in, takeout, delivery, and celebrations. The cooking is broad, generous American-Italian comfort food with Greek and Mediterranean touches, but it is more adventurous than the name suggests. Pizza remains the anchor, especially the square format, House Special, BBQ chicken, and creative combinations such as blackberry with goat cheese and hot honey; pasta, focaccia, shrimp, salads, and chicken dishes also receive strong praise. The current menu supports an affordable full meal built around $16-23 pizzas and pastas, though large specialty orders, delivery, and occasional uneven sandwiches or sides can change the value equation. Families are especially well served: reviewers mention toddlers, grandchildren, kids' pizza events, spaghetti lunches, pineapple pizza, pizza by the slice, and portions that stretch into leftovers. The menu offers familiar cheese and pepperoni pizza, spaghetti, lasagna, calzones, and chicken dishes, while adults can choose seafood pasta or more creative toppings. It is a strong mixed-age choice, though picky eaters may prefer the straightforward options over the specialty pizzas.
Area vibe: Primarily residential-commercial corridor with local-serving shops and restaurants.
Safety: Generally safe, daytime activity with adequate lighting and moderate evening foot traffic but quieter at night.
What's nearby: Near Interlake Ave N, close to Green Lake, Woodland Park and Aurora Ave N transit and auto routes; local shops and light industry nearby.