Seemor

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Don MillsB+Worth Trying

Name: Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Don Mills
Address: 67 O'Neill Rd, North York, ON M3C 0H2, Canada, North York, Canada
Rating: 4.8

67 O'Neill Rd, North York, ON M3C 0H2, Canada · Italian restaurant, Bar & grill, Cocktail bar · 4.8/5 Google (4544 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Lively modern Italian spot with standout fresh mozzarella, solid pastas, and personable service; great for groups, though service speed and takeout quality can be inconsistent.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality in house-made pastas and fresh mozzarella, plus warm, attentive service that earns repeat visits. However, inconsistent execution on takeout and during peak service windows and occasional delays in course timing prevent a higher grade. The attractive setting within Shops at Don Mills suits celebrations and groups well, making it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants.

Restaurant Summary

Set inside the Shops at Don Mills, Scaddabush feels warm and bustling with giant chandeliers and an enclosed patio that catches natural light. Staff energy stands out; several diners mention servers by name, noting service that is warm and attentive. One guest summed up the vibe: "Our server kept perfect timing and made thoughtful suggestions." Big groups and celebrations fit right in. The cooking leans modern comfort Italian: house-made pastas, tableside fresh mozzarella, and truffle-kissed sauces rather than showy tricks. Expect rich, satisfying plates like rigatoni Bolognese or lemon garlic shrimp spaghetti, plus crowd-pleasing chicken parm and shareable desserts. Dine-in execution earns consistent praise; takeout draws more mixed notes on texture and temperature, so plan to enjoy it on-site when possible. Families do well here. Kids gravitate to pizza and simple pastas, and portions suit sharing. There is no explicit kids menu mentioned in recent reviews, but fries, Margherita-style pizzas, and plain tomato spaghetti are safe picks. Note occasional waits at peak times; reservations help when dining with little ones.

At a Glance

Personable servers with helpful recommendations
House-made pasta and fresh mozzarella are crowd favorites
Great for birthdays and large groups
Service speed and course timing can lag at peak hours
Takeout quality and portions less consistent than dine-in

What Sets It Apart

tableside fresh mozzarella
enclosed patio ambiance
large-party handling

What People Love

Warm, attentive servers who remember details
Satisfying, rich pastas and sauces
Tableside fresh mozzarella experience
Atmosphere that feels lively but comfortable

Points of Concern

Service delays and bill timing reported on busy nights though many visits are smooth
Takeout orders can arrive oily, overcooked, or missing items compared to dine-in
Occasional seating or host decisions frustrate guests (dark tables, reservation mix-ups)
Pricing is genuinely expensive (many mains C$25+), which may surprise casual diners

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average CostC$48-68 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Start with 'Nduja & Stracciatella or Balsamic Truffle Mozzarella (C$21-26)
Choose one fresh pasta in the C$24-29 range plus a shareable main
Save room for the Blood Orange & Amaro Cheesecake (C$16.50) to share

Perfect For

Birthday dinners with a crowd
Casual date nights
Family meals after shopping
Work group celebrations

Location Insights

Area: Open-air lifestyle center with retail and dining, attracts shoppers, families, and date-night crowds.

Safety: Well-lit, busy commercial plaza with steady foot traffic; perceived safe and maintained.

Nearby: Surrounded by shops, cinemas, and cafes; convenient pre- and post-meal strolling.

Don MillsDon Mills is a well-established neighborhood with a blend of residential homes, shopping plazas, and office parks. The dining scene includes casual and family-friendly restaurants, with a focus on accessible, comfortable dining experiences. The area is safe, accessible, and popular for both local residents and visitors from surrounding neighborhoods.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–22:00 Tuesday11:00–22:00 Wednesday11:00–22:00 Thursday11:00–23:00 Friday11:00–23:00 Saturday11:00–23:00 Sunday11:00–22:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →