Creative modern bistro-gastropub with standout burger, crudo, and small plates in a cozy, lively room; delicious but pricey with occasional service inconsistency—check the compact menu first.
The Old York Tavern delivers solid neighborhood dining with standout food quality—the burger, crudo, and stracciatella earn consistent praise—and appealing corner setting with a popular patio. However, inconsistent execution across service pacing and occasional dish-level misses prevent a higher grade. Premium pricing with refined portions positions it as a worth crossing town for destination rather than everyday favorite, competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely expensive (C$26-38 mains; steak at C$53); portions can feel modest