Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Budget-friendly New York-style slices and family deals with fast, friendly service; quality is generally good but with occasional misses on wings, sauce, and consistency.
An old-school slice shop energy runs through Mario's: counter orders, big pies, and friendly staff who keep things moving. One diner put it plainly: "The slices were huge and ready fast." The setting is practical more than pretty, and a few guests mention a sketchy-feeling area. Cleanliness impressions vary, but most come for the budget-friendly slices and speed. The cooking leans classic New York-style comfort: foldable slices, familiar toppings, hearty subs, and red-sauce pastas. Expect reliable standbys like Mario's Special and a value-forward 20 inch pie. When they are on, the pizza is hot, cheesy, and satisfying; hiccups tend to be floppy crust or bland sauce, and wings can be under-sauced. This is about value and volume more than culinary experimentation. Families are well covered. There is a kids menu, basic cheese and pepperoni, chicken fingers, and generous family specials that feed a crowd without stress. For cautious eaters, stick to simple pies and sides; adventurous choices are not required here. Budget-minded parents will appreciate the slice-and-drink combo and the family spaghetti trays.
Area: Mixed commercial corridor with budget eats and transit stop; practical rather than scenic.
Safety: Some reviewers note sketchy vibe and cleanliness concerns; generally passable with normal caution.
Nearby: Bus stop out front; near midtown errands, small shops, and residential streets.
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →