Modern downtown pizzeria with standout pastas, craft cocktails, and buzzy vibes; food impresses, but service inconsistency and policy friction can dent the experience.
Reilly Craft Pizza and Drink delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by exceptional housemade pastas and well-executed pizzas, paired with distinctive setting appeal in its historic mortuary space with rooftop views. However, inconsistent execution and service gaps during peak times prevent the higher tier—the lively downtown scene and loyal following make it a worthwhile neighborhood destination, but not yet a regional standout.
One caveat: Service can lag on busy nights; guests reported delayed drinks and limited check-ins