A lively Old Town slice shop turning out crisp, foldable NY-style pizza with strong slice-deal value, but wait times and takeout consistency can be hit-or-miss.
Andy's Pizza Old Town delivers solid neighborhood pizza with crisp crust and balanced sauce that keeps regulars loyal, supported by warm, personable counter service. However, quality varies during busy periods, with occasional soggy or overcooked slices and takeout issues preventing a higher grade. The convenient Old Town location and strong slice value make it a reliable casual stop, though not a destination dining experience.
One caveat: The biggest complaint is inconsistency during rushes: some diners got perfect slices, others got burned, cold, or soggy pizza.