Crispy thin-crust tavern pies with hot oil and stingers are the draw; limited menu, lively bar vibe, fair prices, but service consistency varies.
Colony Grill delivers reliable tavern-style pizza with strong food quality anchored by signature hot oil pies and crisp, lacy crusts that justify repeat visits. However, inconsistent execution across visits—occasional lukewarm pies and uneven toppings—prevents grade A territory, while variable service attentiveness and periodic long waits temper the otherwise friendly, efficient experience. The convenient Clarendon location with comfortable seating and sports atmosphere rounds out a solid neighborhood destination that exceeds typical pizza standards but lacks the polish of premier local establishments.
One caveat: Occasional slow or inattentive service even during non-peak times