Seemor

Fabiani'sB-Worth Trying

Name: Fabiani's
Address: 95 E Lipoa St #101, Kihei, HI 96753, Kihei, United States
Rating: 4.4

95 E Lipoa St #101, Kihei, HI 96753 · Italian restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (1260 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Casual counter-order Italian spot with standout thin-crust pizza and hearty pastas, fair prices for Maui, but inconsistent execution and a few service/value hiccups.

Why it gets a B- for overall quality

Fabiani's delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining anchored by reliable thin-crust pizza and comforting bolognese that earn repeat visits. However, inconsistent execution across pastas and occasional order errors alongside isolated but serious safety incidents prevent a higher grade. The casual, comfortable setting and fair pricing make it a practical choice for families and weeknight dinners, though it lacks the distinction or consistency needed to compete with Kihei's better-regarded establishments.

Restaurant Summary

The scene at Fabiani's is casual and relaxed, a counter-order Italian spot with a roomy bar, AC inside, and a breezy lanai outside. Staff are described as friendly and hardworking, though the hybrid service means you may need to ask for refills. One diner summed it up: "Easygoing place where the pizza comes out crisp and hot." Overall the room feels comfortable and unfussy. Cooking leans classic Italian-American rather than showy: thin-crust pizzas, generous pastas like bolognese, and a small slate of entrees such as mahi or short ribs. When they are on, flavors are comforting and portions satisfy; when they miss, a dish can read bland or over-sauced. Desserts from the in-house bakery are a bright spot, with the cannoli and peanut butter bomb earning smiles. Expect straightforward food that suits casual dinners more than special occasions. For families, this is a practical choice. Pizzas, spaghetti, and garlic focaccia are easy wins, and the outdoor lanai works well with kids. A reviewer noted happy hour deals are bar-seat only, so that is not kid-friendly. Those needing gluten-free should ask about cross-contact on the crust. Overall, plenty that children will actually eat.

At a Glance

Crisp thin-crust pizza and comforting bolognese draw repeat visits
Good portions and fair pricing for Maui
Indoor AC and shaded outdoor lanai seating
Inconsistent execution across pastas and occasional order errors
Counter-service limits proactive refills and follow-up

What Sets It Apart

crisp_thin_crust_pizza
in-house_bakery_desserts
indoor_outdoor_lanai_seating

What People Love

That first crunch of the thin crust
Hearty, savory bolognese that tastes homemade
Desserts that feel like a treat, not an upcharge
Friendly staff who hustle when it gets busy
Solid value compared with nearby resort dining

Points of Concern

Occasional bland or overcooked dishes reported, especially certain pastas
Service gaps due to counter model (water refills, dessert re-ordering at counter)
A few serious but isolated safety complaints (foreign object, sand in water); majority do not report issues
Happy hour restricted to bar seats; families may miss deals

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$40-58 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Pair a $27-31 entree with shared garlic focaccia and finish with a bakery dessert for balanced value
Choose pizza plus a side Caesar for a shareable, lower-cost meal

Perfect For

Casual family dinner after the beach
Pizza and dessert night on a budget (for Maui)
Takeout to feed a condo group
Low-key date on the lanai

Location Insights

Area: Suburban Maui beach town center with locals and visitors; relaxed strip-mall setting near services and condos.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked area; typical parking lot lighting and foot traffic for a neighborhood center.

Nearby: Situated in South Maui Center near shops and a small bookstore; short drive from beach condos and resorts.

North KiheiNorth Kihei is a vibrant area with a mix of residential neighborhoods and commercial zones featuring casual eateries, beachside cafes, and shops. The dining scene is relaxed and family-friendly, often catering to visitors looking for affordable and diverse food options near the beach.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday14:00–20:00 Tuesday14:00–20:00 Wednesday14:00–20:00 Thursday14:00–20:00 Friday11:00–21:00 Saturday11:00–21:00 Sunday11:00–20:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →