Big-flavor Italian American sandwiches and Sicilian/NY slices with limited seating; standout chicken parm and What The? sandwich, but some recent bread changes, occasional service lapses, and a few food safety complaints noted.
Nonna's delivers strong food quality with signature items like chicken parm and the What The? sandwich that drive genuine customer loyalty, supported by prime Randolph Row location. However, inconsistent execution with recent bread changes and occasional soggy slices, combined with isolated food safety incidents, prevents a higher grade.
One caveat: Seating is extremely limited; expect lines and waits at peak times