Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Splashy River North Italian with lively vibes, standout tableside cacio e pepe, and attentive servers like Anthony—excellent for occasions, but noise, pace, and uneven pasta execution can frustrate.
Olio e Più delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional setting appeal and warm, attentive service that elevates the experience. However, inconsistent pasta execution—with standout cacio e pepe and ravioli offset by variable carbonara and seasoning—prevents grade A territory. The River North location and lively atmosphere make it worth a visit for occasion dining, though perfectionists should expect occasional disappointment.
Step into River North where the room feels old-world and ethereal, the doors swing open to the street, and the buzz tilts lively. Service is often warm and attentive—several diners credit servers by name—and the night can sparkle with little touches like an amuse-bouche. One guest summed it up: "We felt pampered and taken care of here." Do note the lively atmosphere can turn loud on weekends. The cooking leans classic Italian with polish rather than theatrics—an elevated traditional approach featuring crudo, steaks, and housemade pastas. The tableside cacio e pepe is the showpiece; when dialed in, it sings, and the short rib ravioli and branzino also draw praise. Still, feedback on carbonara and seasoning varies, so perfection seekers should target the most consistent favorites. Families will find kid-approachable options like burger, chicken piccata, and simple pastas, though portions skew European and the room gets loud at peak times. Customization for strict diets can be limited, but there are vegetarian items and some gluten-free notes. For a smoother family night, aim for earlier seatings and stick to the familiar crowd-pleasers.
Area: Bustling River North hub with nightlife, hotels, and upscale-casual dining; draws locals and visitors.
Safety: Well-trafficked, generally safe, busy evenings; typical downtown awareness advised.
Nearby: Near offices, galleries, hotels, and other restaurants; easy post-dinner bar options.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →