Old-school Italian near Steppenwolf with solid pastas and friendly servers, but inconsistent execution, some brusque hosting, and value concerns; best for pre-theater if you manage timing.
Trattoria Gianni delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining with genuine strengths in prime pre-theater location and warm, attentive service, but inconsistent food execution—ranging from excellent chicken Marsala to bland or overcooked plates—prevents a higher grade. The classic trattoria approach suits regulars and theater-goers seeking reliable comfort rather than culinary distinction, though occasional service friction and variable pacing temper the experience.
One caveat: Calamari and some seafood pastas arrive bland or cool on busy nights