Seemor

Brant Point GrillB+Worth Trying

Name: Brant Point Grill
Address: White Elephant, 50 Easton St, Nantucket, MA 02554, Nantucket, United States
Rating: 4.4

White Elephant, 50 Easton St, Nantucket, MA 02554 · Seafood restaurant, Bar & grill, Fine dining restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (248 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Outdoor seating

Waterfront views and polished service shine; food ranges from good to middling at very expensive prices, best for scenic drinks, raw bar, and brunch over high-stakes dinners.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Brant Point Grill delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional harbor views and a beautifully refreshed terrace that justify its resort destination appeal. Warm, responsive service and reliable standouts like raw bar and chowder are genuine strengths, but inconsistent execution on steaks and lobster mains prevents higher-grade territory. Best experienced for views, brunch, and raw bar rather than as a destination for consistent fine dining.

Restaurant Summary

Set on the harbor within the White Elephant, Brant Point Grill delivers a polished waterfront scene with a newly refreshed terrace and sweeping views. Diners describe service as warm and professional, with one noting, "Our server made the evening feel effortless," while the sunset patio steals the show. Expect a resort vibe where the view-forward setting is a defining part of the experience. The cooking reads as elevated New England with steakhouse leanings—think oysters, chowder, lobster rolls, and prime cuts—with contemporary touches rather than theatrics. Highlights like fresh raw bar, chowder, and tuna appetizers draw praise, while some mains (steaks, lobster mac) can land bland or overcooked. Best bets: raw bar, classic seafood, and brunch items; dinner entrees can be uneven, so order where the kitchen shows consistent confidence. Families do well here thanks to the spacious terrace and lawn where kids can move around, plus comfort staples like burgers, fries, pasta, and French toast at breakfast. There is no dedicated kids menu mentioned, but several familiar options exist; adventurous dishes may not suit picky eaters.

At a Glance

Stunning harbor views and refreshed terrace
Friendly, polished service with good hospitality
Raw bar, chowder, and brunch items are reliable standouts
Inconsistent execution on some mains (overcooking, bland seasoning)
Very expensive pricing aligned to resort setting

What Sets It Apart

harbor_view_terrace
resort_access_at_white_elephant
robust_raw_bar

What People Love

The serene harbor panorama
Easygoing yet refined service
Fresh oysters and solid chowder
Relaxed resort atmosphere on the terrace
Space for kids to play nearby

Points of Concern

Pricing is genuinely high (many mains $44-$89) which may surprise casual diners
Quality can vary—reports of bland lobster mac and overcooked fish/steaks
Occasional rushed service during shift changes or busy sunsets

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$90-125 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Start with oysters and chowder, follow with grilled swordfish or tuna; at lunch, the lobster roll or prime burger are safer bets; for breakfast, choose lobster Benedict or short rib hash.

Perfect For

Sunset cocktails and oysters with a view
Special-occasion summer dinners
Brunch on the terrace
Group gatherings at a resort setting

Location Insights

Area: Upscale waterfront resort setting near Brant Point lighthouse, aimed at resort guests and special-occasion diners.

Safety: Well-maintained, highly trafficked resort area with strong safety presence and good lighting.

Nearby: Within White Elephant resort complex; near harbor, Children’s Beach, and Brant Point Lighthouse.

Nantucket TownNantucket Town is the island's main hub, featuring a blend of historic charm and modern luxury. The dining scene is upscale with a focus on seafood and New England cuisine, catering to well-heeled visitors and locals alike. The atmosphere is relaxed yet refined, with many waterfront and fine dining options.

Easton StreetEaston Street is known for its proximity to the harbor and the White Elephant Hotel, offering scenic views and a selection of high-end restaurants and bars. It is a favored spot for dining with a waterfront ambiance and a sophisticated yet casual vibe.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →