Seemor
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint (Silver Lake)BWorth Trying
2457 Hyperion Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90027
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant, Pasta shop
· 4.5/5 Google (607 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Lively Silver Lake slice shop serving crisp NY-style pies and Sicilian squares with gluten-free options; great pizza value by-the-slice, whole pies skew pricier and delivery hiccups occur.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint delivers solid neighborhood pizza through strong food quality anchored by crisp NY-style slices and legit Grandma squares, paired with friendly counter service and quick execution. Consistency shows occasional variation—burnt spots and soft pies surface alongside reliable regulars—while the casual Silver Lake setting appeals locally but lacks destination pull. Solid value for slices keeps it competitive with respected neighborhood favorites, though whole pies feel pricey for the category.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels small and cozy with a steady flow of folks grabbing slices, families posting up on the back patio, and staff who are usually friendly at the counter. One diner summed it up simply: "Crisp crust, tangy sauce, and a proper NY-style slice." The vibe is neighborhood-first, quick, and unfussy. Cooking here leans classic NY and Sicilian rather than showy—think Grandma squares with real snap, traditional cheese slices, and a few playful detours like BBQ chicken or hot honey drizzles. Gluten-free options are unusually robust for a slice shop, and customization is welcomed. Most praise the pizza; a minority report the odd burnt spot or soft pie, plus delivery hiccups when systems act up. For families, this is easy mode: cheese or pepperoni slices, wings, and simple salads keep kids happy, and there is a casual patio for messy eaters. There is no kids menu, but the menu fits kid tastes naturally. Heads-up: mosquitoes can visit the patio in warmer months, so consider indoor seats if that is a concern.
At a Glance
- Crisp NY-style slices and legit Grandma squares win consistent praise
- Strong gluten-free program with multiple specialty pies
- Whole pies can feel pricey compared to slices
- Delivery/order system glitches and zone limits frustrate some
- Occasional execution slips (burnt spots, cold or soft pie)
What Sets It Apart
- authentic_ny_style_slices
- strong_gluten_free_program
- grandma_and_sicilian_specialties
What People Love
- That first bite crunch on the Grandma
- Garlic knots with pesto upgrade
- Friendly counter energy
- Consistent slice selection with variety
Points of Concern
- Pricing feels high to some for whole pies; slices offer better perceived value
- Delivery-zone limits and approval delays caused missed meals for a few diners
- Quality variance reported: occasional burnt, cold, or bland cheese pies
- Patio comfort varies; mosquitoes mentioned in warmer months
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-34 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Gluten-free diners: order Miss Green or Mr. White on GF crust; reviews confirm good texture
- Value play: pair a $3.25-4.50 slice with $6.25 knots for a satisfying budget meal
- Sharing: split a Grandma and add wings for texture and heat contrast
Perfect For
- Quick slice before or after Griffith Park
- Family-friendly casual dinner
- Gluten-free pizza seekers
- Neighborhood takeout night
Location Insights
Area: Trendy, residential-meets-creative corridor with casual eateries and coffee spots; draws families, locals, and artists.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; standard urban caution at night.
Nearby: Near Griffith Park/Observatory routes, cafes, and indie shops along Hyperion and Sunset Junction.
Silver LakeSilver Lake is characterized by its bohemian vibe, with many independent coffee shops, casual dining spots, and artisanal food venues. The dining scene is casual yet innovative, often featuring locally sourced ingredients and a focus on unique, quality offerings. It is a popular area for those seeking a laid-back but culturally rich atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–21:00
Tuesday11:00–21:00
Wednesday11:00–21:00
Thursday11:00–21:00
Friday11:00–21:00
Saturday11:00–21:00
Sunday11:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →