Seemor
Amber Restaurant & Whisky BarA-Worth Trying
354 Castlehill, Edinburgh EH1 2NE
· Scottish restaurant, Bar, Coffee shop
· 4.7/5 Google (1508 reviews)
Reservations
Welcoming modern Scottish dining with standout whisky pairings and reliable classics next to the Castle; book ahead, expect fair prices and occasional service pacing hiccups.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Amber Restaurant & Whisky Bar delivers confident modern Scottish cooking with standout desserts and exceptional whisky expertise, supported by prime Old Town location and polished ambiance. Friendly, knowledgeable service and a strong children's menu enhance the experience, though occasional pacing delays and consistency variability on set menus prevent grade A territory. A reliable neighborhood favorite that exceeds typical restaurant standards in the area.
Restaurant Summary
Set just off the Royal Mile inside the Scotch Whisky Experience, the room feels warm and polished without the fuss. Service skews friendly and whisky-savvy, with one guest noting, "Our bartender built a flight around what we like and explained every dram," while another praised the quiet, elegant atmosphere. Peak times can bring groups, so energy rises, but for most visits it lands as relaxed and welcoming. The kitchen leans modern Scottish with classic comfort at heart, not showy—think haggis with whisky sauce, lamb stovies, grilled sea trout, and a beloved sticky toffee pudding. The approach is elevated traditional (innovation level 5.6): refined sauces, local produce, and whisky pairings rather than culinary theatrics. A £55 Taste of Scotland menu offers breadth and a paired dram; most find it fun, though a few wish for bigger portions or more finesse at busy times. Families are well looked after. There is a real children's menu with simple mains, sandwiches, and smaller desserts, and staff have even handed out coloring sheets. If your kid likes familiar flavors, the children’s haggis and mash or sea trout with potatoes are safe bets; picky eaters can default to soup or a cheese sandwich. Strollers and walk-ins might be trickier at peak group times, so book ahead if timing matters.
At a Glance
- Confident modern Scottish cooking with standout desserts and whisky pairings
- Friendly, knowledgeable team—excellent whisky guidance
- Strong kids menu and family-welcoming touches
- Walk-ins sometimes refused due to group bookings; reservations advised
- Pacing can slow during events; occasional overcooked or dry items on set menus
What Sets It Apart
- deep_whisky_program
- taste_of_scotland_menu
- castlehill_location
- strong_kids_menu_for_cuisine_type
What People Love
- Warm, helpful whisky guidance that demystifies the menu
- Comforting Scottish staples with polished execution
- Sticky toffee pudding that wins repeat praise
- Calm, elegant setting steps from the Castle
- The option to sample widely via the Taste of Scotland menu
Points of Concern
- Walk-in refusals when groups are booked despite empty tables—plan to reserve
- Occasional slow pacing between courses or when paying during events
- A few reports of dry chicken or tough beef on set/tasting menus
- Solo diners reported being turned away in isolated cases
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£36-48 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair sticky toffee pudding with a recommended Speyside or Highland dram for a caramel echo
- Vegetarian diners should consider potato dumplings with wild mushrooms (£14.95) plus the cheese selection (£14.50) to share
- Budget-friendly lunch: soup of the day (£3.50) with a sandwich (£6.95-£7.95) and split a dessert
Perfect For
- Pre-castle or pre-Tattoo dinner with a whisky flight
- Date night that is relaxed but special
- Visitors seeking Scottish classics done well
- Families wanting a kid-friendly option in Old Town
Location Insights
Area: Historic Old Town adjacent to the Castle and Scotch Whisky Experience; heavy tourist footfall with steady local interest.
Safety: High foot traffic, well-patrolled tourist zone; generally safe and well-lit.
Nearby: Scotch Whisky Experience on-site, Edinburgh Castle nearby, Royal Mile shops and attractions within steps.
CastlehillCastlehill is a prominent street within Edinburgh's Old Town, running along the edge of the Royal Mile and adjacent to Edinburgh Castle. The dining scene here caters largely to visitors with a mix of traditional Scottish pubs, upscale restaurants, and casual eateries, often bustling with tourists during the day and early evening. The area is lively, historic, and well-maintained, with a strong emphasis on heritage and hospitality.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–22:00
Tuesday11:30–22:00
Wednesday11:30–22:00
Thursday11:30–22:00
Friday11:30–22:00
Saturday11:30–22:00
Sunday11:30–22:00
Available: Reservations
View full analysis on Seemor →