A lively Old Town spot that is strongest on fresh fish and chips, friendly service, and broad comfort-food appeal, but watch for occasional consistency issues and a mandatory service charge that catches some diners off guard.
Auld Town Fish & Chips delivers very good food quality anchored by fresh fish, haddock, and pies that earn consistent praise, paired with attentive and welcoming service that sets a high standard for casual dining. A slight dip in consistency around chips and seasoning, combined with modest design ambiance that relies heavily on its Old Town location rather than distinctive interior character, keeps it just short of the very top tier.
One caveat: A minority of diners found the chips soft, lukewarm, or less crisp than expected.