Monteiths is a cosy, destination-style Royal Mile restaurant with genuinely strong Scottish food, a memorable drinks list, and a polished atmosphere, but portion size, pricing, and occasional service lapses keep it from feeling like a slam-dunk.
Monteiths delivers exceptional food quality anchored by well-executed Scottish plates, seafood, and game that keep diners returning, while its dark, classy design creates a genuine sense of discovery. Strong service knowledge on drinks and whisky pairings, combined with polished attentiveness, elevates the experience, though occasional inconsistencies in doneness and portion control prevent a flawless showing.
One caveat: Portions are frequently called small relative to the bill, especially for mains.