Seemor
The Piper's RestB+Worth Trying
3 Hunter Square, Edinburgh EH1 1QW
· Restaurant, Bar, Pub
· 4.5/5 Google (3183 reviews)
Reservations · Outdoor seating
Lively Old Town pub-restaurant serving hearty Scottish classics with standout Cullen skink and steak pie; great vibes and attentive staff, but expect waits, auto service charge, and occasional service hiccups.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Piper's Rest delivers solid neighborhood dining through strong food quality anchored by standout Scottish classics like Cullen skink, and attentive, personable service that keeps regulars returning. However, inconsistent execution on certain dishes and crowding during peak hours prevent it from reaching higher territory. A reliable, warmly-staffed pub that excels at what it does without pretension.
Restaurant Summary
A cosy Old Town spot where Scottish comfort food meets pub warmth, The Piper's Rest hums with live music energy and friendly faces. Diners rave about attentive servers like Dan and Grace, and one guest gushed that the soup in the bread loaf was "worth a return trip." Expect a bustling, cheerful room and the occasional wait during peak times. The cooking leans hearty and traditional with playful nods to local quirks: Cullen skink served in a crusty loaf, slow-braised steak pie, and even an Irn-Bru panna cotta. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional (innovation level 5.4): robust flavors, generous portions, and pub classics done right rather than culinary theatrics. Prices reflect the central location, but many feel the portions and atmosphere justify it. Families fare well here thanks to a dedicated kids menu (nuggets, mac and cheese, burgers) and a lineup of familiar, comforting mains. Even cautious eaters can find friendly options like mac, fish and chips, or burgers, while adventurous diners can dive into haggis and hearty soups. Arrive earlier on weekends if you need a high chair or extra space.
At a Glance
- Standout Cullen skink and hearty Scottish classics
- Warm, lively pub atmosphere with live music
- Attentive staff frequently praised by name
- Peak-time waits; reservations advised
- Reports of auto-added service charge and charity line
What Sets It Apart
- Cullen_skink_in_bread_bowl
- live_scottish_music
- broad_whisky_selection
- family_friendly_menu
What People Love
- That bread-bowl Cullen skink moment
- Friendly servers who keep drinks topped up
- Big, satisfying portions that feel like a hug
- Lively music that energizes the room
Points of Concern
- Busy peaks mean 10-30 minute waits; book or come early
- Service charge and charity donation lines can appear by default; review bill
- Occasional dry or overcooked mains when slammed
- A few reports of brusque staff interactions contrast with many positives
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£34-46 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Haggis Tower (veg), Clan Mac, Lentil Soup
- For gluten-free: Poke O' Chips, Lemon Pepper Salmon (GF), request GF options on burgers and mussels
Perfect For
- First-timers seeking Scottish classics near Royal Mile
- Casual group dinners with live music ambiance
- Families wanting kid-friendly comfort food
- Whisky sips with a hearty pie on a chilly night
Location Insights
Area: Touristed Old Town hub near Royal Mile; lively pubs, historic sights, heavy foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe with constant footfall; late-night crowds can feel rowdy to some.
Nearby: Steps from Royal Mile, close to attractions, hotels, and nightlife; frequent live music venues nearby.
Royal MileThe Royal Mile is a bustling stretch filled with historic sites, pubs, restaurants, and shops catering largely to tourists and visitors. Dining options range from traditional Scottish fare to casual eateries, with a lively atmosphere especially during festivals and peak tourist seasons.
Hunter SquareHunter Square is a small plaza off the Royal Mile, known for its proximity to St Giles' Cathedral and a mix of casual dining spots and cafes. It offers a slightly quieter dining environment compared to the main thoroughfare but remains busy during the day with visitors and nearby workers.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–01:00
Tuesday10:00–01:00
Wednesday10:00–01:00
Thursday10:00–01:00
Friday10:00–01:00
Saturday10:00–01:00
Sunday10:00–01:00
Available: Reservations, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →