A cozy Old Town bistro with standout views, hearty Scottish-leaning dishes, and real charm when service is on song, but the inconsistency is significant enough that timing your visit matters.
Maxies Bistro delivers strong setting appeal and solid seafood execution, but inconsistent food quality and variable service across visits prevent a higher grade. The charming basement and terrace draw diners, yet swings from excellent to disappointing dishes, combined with unpredictable pacing during busy periods, keep it from approaching grade A territory.
One caveat: Service delays are the main recurring gripe, and they show up across both older and very recent reviews.