Seemor
Nantucket › Nantucket › Brotherhood of Thieves
Brotherhood of ThievesB+Worth Trying
23 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554
· American restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (958 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
A lively historic pub-restaurant with a broad American menu plus sushi, strong seafood and burgers, bustling service that can lag, and prices on the high side for Nantucket.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Brotherhood of Thieves delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong seafood execution and attentive staff anchoring the experience. The historic tavern setting with multiple rooms creates genuine character, though inconsistent execution during peak service and occasional slowdowns prevent grade A territory. Competitive with the area's better local restaurants for seafood and casual dining.
Restaurant Summary
Walk down into the old tavern and you get that warm, historic pub vibe—timbered ceilings, dim booths, and a lively hum from the bar upstairs. Servers like Brooke and Peter earn shout-outs, and one diner raved, "Our group was handled smoothly even when it was packed." However, expect occasional waits at peak times when the room is busy and buzzing. The cooking spans New England staples and creative touches: oysters, lobster rolls, blackened swordfish, and even sushi alongside crowd-pleasers like spicy rigatoni. It leans contemporary pub with playful fusion—chimichurri, yuzu, and Thai flavors show up without feeling fussy. If you love seafood and hearty plates, you will find plenty to like; value feels fair for the island when portions land as generously as the fish and chips. Families are welcome—there are kid-friendly classics like burgers, fries, and tenders plus simple seafood, and the cookie skillet is a hit. There is no formal kids menu listed, but the menu has accessible choices; picky eaters can stick to burgers or chowder while adventurous teens can try poke or sushi.
At a Glance
- Historic tavern ambiance with multiple rooms and an upstairs bar
- Strong seafood and lobster rolls with generous portions
- Broad menu including sushi and creative twists
- Service can slow or stumble during peak times and holidays
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- historic_tavern_ambience
- broad_menu_with_sushi
- multiple_bars_and_rooms
- group_friendly_spaces
What People Love
- Atmosphere feels like stepping into island history
- Lobster rolls and swordfish done right
- Cookie skillet dessert for sharing
- Friendly servers who offer smart recommendations
- Sushi and poke as unexpected bonuses
Points of Concern
- Service lags and host issues reported at peak times and holidays, though many visits run smoothly
- Noise and crowding in the pub rooms during rush hours
- Pricing is genuinely expensive ($22-44 mains) which may surprise casual diners
- Review patterns are consistent with potential coordination (enthusiastic superlatives) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$58-82 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For seafood lovers: oysters to start, blackened swordfish or lobster roll; for land options: Brotherhood burger and spicy rigatoni; finish with the cookie skillet.
Perfect For
- Casual seafood dinner after the Whaling Museum
- Group meals with mixed tastes
- Bar seating with oysters and a cocktail
- Families seeking approachable options
Location Insights
Area: Historic downtown Nantucket with tourist foot traffic, boutiques, and bars; lively in season, relaxed off-season.
Safety: Generally safe, well-patrolled historic district with steady foot traffic; occasional crowded peak evenings.
Nearby: Steps from Whaling Museum, harbor, shops, and galleries; convenient for pre- or post-sightseeing meals.
Nantucket TownNantucket Town is the main commercial and cultural hub of the island, featuring a variety of dining options from casual pubs to fine dining. The atmosphere is relaxed yet vibrant, catering to visitors seeking authentic New England coastal experiences alongside locals.
Broad StreetBroad Street is known for its lively bar and restaurant scene, popular for casual dining and social gatherings, especially during the tourist season.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–21:00
Tuesday11:30–21:00
Wednesday11:30–21:00
Thursday11:30–21:00
Friday11:30–22:00
Saturday11:30–22:00
Sunday11:30–21:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →