A lively historic pub-restaurant with a broad American menu plus sushi, strong seafood and burgers, bustling service that can lag, and prices on the high side for Nantucket.
Brotherhood of Thieves delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong seafood execution and attentive staff anchoring the experience. The historic tavern setting with multiple rooms creates genuine character, though inconsistent execution during peak service and occasional slowdowns prevent grade A territory. Competitive with the area's better local restaurants for seafood and casual dining.
One caveat: Service lags and host issues reported at peak times and holidays, though many visits run smoothly