Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
A lively Soho Italian with creative pastas, generous portions, and a few service hiccups—worth it for food lovers, but not for those seeking flawless hospitality.
Mele e Pere delivers reliable Italian comfort food with strong pasta and pizza execution in a vibrant Soho setting that appeals to groups and pre-theatre diners. However, inconsistent quality and service reliability across visits, combined with variable service attentiveness during busy periods, prevents it from reaching higher distinction. The generous portions and good value make it a solid neighborhood choice, though not among the area's premier Italian destinations.
Mele e Pere brings a slice of lively Italian hospitality to the heart of Soho, offering a menu packed with homemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and a few creative flourishes like duck ragu with truffle. The atmosphere is casual and energetic, with a bustling bar and a large downstairs dining area perfect for groups or pre-theatre gatherings. Expect generous portions and a menu that balances Italian classics with a few modern twists, all served in a setting that's as much about the vibe as the food. Culinarily, Mele e Pere leans toward traditional Italian comfort food with a touch of creativity—think rich carbonara, pillowy focaccia, and the occasional truffle-laced pasta. The menu is broad enough to please most diners, with standout dishes like the spaghetti alla carbonara and tiramisu earning rave reviews. While not a temple of avant-garde cuisine, the kitchen delivers on flavor and authenticity, making it a solid choice for those who crave hearty, well-executed Italian fare. For families, Mele e Pere is a reliable bet: the menu features plenty of kid-friendly options like Margherita pizza, simple pastas, and chips. Several reviews mention children enjoying their meals, and the generous portions mean no one leaves hungry. While a few diners wished for even more variety for vegetarians, the current menu offers a solid selection of meat-free and gluten-free dishes. If your little ones are adventurous, they'll find plenty to love; if they're picky, the classics will do the trick.
Area: Bustling, trendy Soho location with a mix of creative professionals, tourists, and theatre-goers. Lively, energetic, and cosmopolitan.
Safety: Generally safe, high foot traffic, well-lit at night, but busy and sometimes crowded.
Nearby: Surrounded by theatres, bars, and other restaurants; close to shopping and nightlife.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →