Creative burgers with house sauces in Polanco; tasty and sizable, but service speed and tipping practices can frustrate on busy nights.
Butcher and Sons Polanco delivers strong food quality with flavorful, generously-sized burgers and creative house sauces that justify its reputation among burger enthusiasts. However, quality variability across visits—particularly temperature and doneness inconsistencies—and weekend wait times that stretch during delivery surges prevent it from reaching higher territory. The desirable Polanco location with outdoor seating adds appeal, making it a solid neighborhood choice for casual dining rather than a destination establishment.
On the Polanquito strip, this spot feels cozy and bustling with sidewalk tables and house sauces lined up like a tasting flight. Reviews praise the burgers as big and flavorful, with several calling out the trio of ketchups. One diner noted, "The curry sauce with the spicy one was my favorite combo." Busy nights can strain the system, though, and waits stretch when delivery orders stack up. The cooking leans elevated comfort: classic burger bones upgraded with raclette, foie gras, and a wagyu smash, plus playful sides like bacon-wrapped fries. Drinks lean easygoing—cocktails, micheladas, and their own beer—making it a solid casual dinner pick in Polanco. Most find prices fair for the area, though a few feel the execution does not always match the premium. Families are generally comfortable here: burgers, fries, nuggets, and milkshakes check the boxes, and there is a vegan patty plus veggie sides for mixed diets. Space is tight outside near the street, so strollers may be awkward at peak times. If you come on weekends, arrive early to avoid the longer waits that parents tend to dread.
Area vibe: Upscale, walkable Polanco strip with cafes, boutiques, and nightlife; attracts locals and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe, busy sidewalks and lighting; typical big-city pickpocket awareness advised.
What's nearby: Near Polanquito dining cluster, parks, luxury retail on Masaryk, offices and hotels.