Destination for Hidalgo-style barbacoa with handmade tortillas and rich consomé; excellent food, lively vibe, but expect crowds, upsells, and higher prices with some service inconsistencies.
El Hidalguense delivers exceptional barbacoa with rich consomé and handmade tortillas that justify its Roma Sur reputation and destination appeal. However, inconsistent execution—ranging from stellar to reheated and greasy cuts—and variable service during weekend rushes prevent grade A territory. The lively setting and generous portions make it worth visiting for adventurous eaters seeking authentic Hidalgo-style cooking, though arrive early and expect price premiums.
One caveat: Pricing surprises with chapulines add-on reported by multiple diners