Kosher Argentinian steakhouse in Polanco delivering solid grilled meats, wide menu, and attentive service; prices are high and service consistency varies, with occasional automatic gratuity complaints.
Gaucho Grill delivers competitive quality for Polanco's kosher dining scene, with well-executed steaks and Argentinian specialties and attentive service that often impresses. However, inconsistent execution—ranging from perfectly cooked meats to occasional overcooking— and variable service pacing on busy nights prevent it from reaching higher territory. The elegant Polanco setting and family-friendly menu are strengths, but premium pricing and reliability concerns keep it in solid neighborhood-restaurant territory rather than destination status.
One caveat: Service speed can lag at peak times; a few felt ignored or seated out of order