Polanco Italian spot with polished pastas, serious wine glasses, and mixed reports on service; food can shine but policies and charges frustrate some diners.
Romina delivers respectable Italian dining anchored by strong pasta execution and desserts plus a standout wine program. However, quality variation in sauces and proteins and inconsistent service warmth—ranging from attentive to dismissive—prevent grade A-level consistency. The polished Polanco location appeals to date-night diners, but rigid policies and surprise charges temper the overall experience for a grade B standing.
In polished Polanco, this room feels cozy and intimate rather than flashy. Servers pour confidently and the stemware is a talking point, with one guest raving that the glasses beat many high-end spots. However, there are some review authenticity concerns and a pattern of firm house policies that can rub people the wrong way when issues arise. The cooking leans elevated Italian with a produce-first sensibility: al dente ribbons in lamb ragù, clean crudos, and a tiramisu that wins repeat praise. Expect classic flavors with a few modern touches rather than fireworks, and a thoughtful wine pairing culture for those who like to be guided. Families may find a few wins like rigatoni cacio e pepe or lasagna, but the menu is compact and the room stays quiet. There is no kids menu, portions trend modest, and policies around seating and groups are strict—better for patient, pasta-loving kids than picky eaters.
Area vibe: Upscale shopping and dining corridor catering to business crowds and evening leisure in Polanco.
Safety: Well-patrolled, high foot traffic, generally safe with good lighting and maintenance.
What's nearby: Near boutiques, galleries, luxury hotels, and corporate offices; lively evenings and weekends.
Standout pastas and tiramisù are must-orders at Romina.
Know about strict house policies, surprise charges, and modest portions before you go.
Romina feels polished and intimate, more date-night than party spot.