Cozy Sardinian spot with standout house-made pasta and focaccia, good service, and solid value via lunch specials; a few consistency hiccups and occasional service lapses to note.
Arco Cafe delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional house-made pastas and focaccia paired with warm, attentive service. Occasional execution inconsistencies and a compact intimate space prevent higher standing, though strong loyalty and positive recent momentum confirm this Upper West Side neighborhood gem merits its reputation.
One caveat: Isolated reports of over-salted dishes or overcooked mussels