Seemor
Arco CafeA-Worth Trying
886 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025
· Italian restaurant, Pasta shop, Restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (524 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Cozy Sardinian spot with standout house-made pasta and focaccia, good service, and solid value via lunch specials; a few consistency hiccups and occasional service lapses to note.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Arco Cafe delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional house-made pastas and focaccia paired with warm, attentive service. Occasional execution inconsistencies and a compact intimate space prevent higher standing, though strong loyalty and positive recent momentum confirm this Upper West Side neighborhood gem merits its reputation.
Restaurant Summary
A cozy Upper West Side nook where the room feels warm and welcoming and servers move with easy confidence. Diners rave about the house focaccia and pastas, calling out delicate frying and careful pacing. One guest summed it up simply: neighborhood gem. The cooking leans Sardinian and elevated traditional rather than flashy. Expect seafood-forward plates like busa with mixed seafood, satisfying ragus, and riccioli with pistachio. Portions are generous without being heavy, and desserts such as tiramisu land with classic comfort. Families fit right in thanks to kid-pleasing pastas (ragu, cacio-style options) and pizza-adjacent focacce. Vegan-marked starters and salads help with mixed diets. Space is small, so large groups should book ahead and manage expectations.
At a Glance
- House-made pasta and focaccia are consistent standouts
- Friendly, attentive neighborhood service
- Lunch specials offer strong value
- Occasional over-salt or temperature issues on busy nights
- Small space not ideal for big groups
What Sets It Apart
- house_made_sardinian_pasta
- creative_focaccia_menu
- neighborhood_warmth
What People Love
- Warm, welcoming vibe
- Crisp, airy focaccia with creative toppings
- Seafood pasta cooked just right
- Classic tiramisu that hits the spot
Points of Concern
- Isolated reports of over-salted dishes or overcooked mussels
- Temperature inconsistency noted during Restaurant Week rush
- Small tables and tighter seating; plan ahead for groups
- Music volume bothered a few late-night diners
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$45-$60 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair Fritto Misto with a simple salad to start, follow with Tagliatelle al Ragu; finish with Affogato if you want a lighter dessert.
Perfect For
- Date-night pasta and wine
- Weekday lunch special with a friend
- Solo bite at the bar
- Neighborhood family dinner
Location Insights
Area: Residential Upper West Side corridor with student and family mix; relaxed neighborhood dining vibe.
Safety: Generally safe, active foot traffic; isolated reports of sidewalk discomfort at night.
Nearby: Near Columbia-Barnard area, hostels and apartments; many Italian and casual eateries nearby.
Upper West SideThe Upper West Side features a diverse dining scene ranging from casual eateries to upscale restaurants, catering to a well-educated and affluent population. The area is known for its safe, community-oriented atmosphere with a blend of long-term residents and younger professionals, often enjoying a mix of classic New York dining and innovative culinary options.
Morningside HeightsMorningside Heights is a sub-area within the Upper West Side centered around Columbia University, characterized by a youthful and intellectual vibe. Dining options here often include casual cafes, ethnic eateries, and spots popular with students and academics, reflecting a lively yet studious atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–21:30
Tuesday12:00–21:30
Wednesday12:00–21:30
Thursday12:00–21:30
Friday12:00–21:30
Saturday12:00–21:30
Sunday12:00–21:30
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →