Seemor
Brooklyn Pizza MastersBWorth Trying
1055 1st Ave, New York, NY 10022
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (487 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Creative New York slices with crisp crust and premium toppings; strong neighborhood favorite but delivery consistency and service warmth vary.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Brooklyn Pizza Masters delivers excellent food quality with crisp crust and premium toppings that justify its reputation among gourmet slice fans. However, inconsistent execution—particularly cold deliveries and variable service warmth—prevents a higher grade. The compact Midtown location works well for quick neighborhood visits, though cramped seating and mixed recent trends limit broader appeal.
Restaurant Summary
A compact Midtown East slice shop with big-flavor pies and a steady neighborhood crowd. Diners rave about the crisp crust and premium toppings, calling out mushroom-truffle squares and balanced cheese pies. One regular summed it up: "Went in for one slice and immediately ordered another." Service warmth can vary, but many visits feel friendly and fast. The cooking skews classic New York pizza with a gourmet twist—think taleggio, truffle oil, prosciutto, and even blackberry-ricotta. That makes it ideal for folks who love elevated traditional rather than experimental theatrics. Most praise dine-in slices, while delivery can be hit or miss on temperature and timing, so expectations should match the format. Families do well here thanks to kid-friendly staples like cheese and pepperoni plus pastas and garlic knots. The menu also stands out for its gluten-free cauliflower pies and many vegetarian options. Adventurous combos exist, but there is always a safe slice for picky eaters.
At a Glance
- Crisp crust and high-quality toppings earn strong praise
- Extensive gluten-free and vegetarian pizza options
- Delivery can arrive cold or late at times
- Service warmth inconsistent; occasional curt interactions
- Some diners find prices high for slices
What Sets It Apart
- extensive_gluten_free_pizza_range
- elevated_toppings_like_taleggio_and_truffle
- crisp_square_grandma_style
What People Love
- That satisfying crisp undercarriage
- Creative but familiar flavor combos
- Neighborhood vibe with quick service
- Garlic knots and pinwheels as add-ons
Points of Concern
- Delivery consistency issues: several reports of cold or delayed pies
- Occasional dry or soggy crust, especially on reheated slices
- Customer service varies; a few reports of brusque interactions
- Review patterns show minor marketing-tone inflation in some raves but overall appear authentic
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$28-42 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Gluten-free diners: try GF Grandma or GF Quattro Formaggi ($18)
- Vegetarians: Mushroom & Truffle or Quattro Formaggi offer depth without meat
- Value play: share Arancini ($10) then split a $22-25 pie
Perfect For
- Quick post-work slice near Midtown offices
- Casual date over gourmet toppings
- Gluten-free diners seeking real variety
- Out-of-towners sampling NYC-style with upgrades
Location Insights
Area: Busy Midtown East corridor serving office workers, residents, and visitors; fast-casual spots mixed with neighborhood staples.
Safety: Generally safe, high foot traffic, well-lit streets typical of Midtown East.
Nearby: Near offices, hotels, and residential towers; convenient for quick slices, takeaway, and casual dine-in.
Turtle BayTurtle Bay offers a refined dining environment with a variety of upscale restaurants, casual eateries, and international cuisine options. The area is characterized by a mix of corporate offices and residential buildings, attracting a clientele that ranges from business lunch crowds to neighborhood residents seeking quality dining experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–22:00
Tuesday10:00–22:00
Wednesday10:00–22:00
Thursday10:00–22:00
Friday10:00–22:00
Saturday10:00–22:00
Sunday10:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →