Destination for Neapolitan pies with standout gluten-free options and some service rigidity; excellent pizzas on-site, delivery is inconsistent.
Don Antonio delivers excellent Neapolitan pizza with standout gluten-free options and impressive speed that makes it ideal for pre-theater dining in Midtown West. However, inconsistent delivery experiences and variable service attentiveness—particularly at the host stand—prevent a higher grade, while tight seating limits overall comfort. Strong core execution and loyal following position it as a competitive neighborhood favorite rather than a destination standout.
One caveat: Host stand can feel inflexible; limited willingness to modify pies