Seemor

Don AntonioB+Worth Trying

Name: Don Antonio
Address: Don Antonio's Pizza, 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, New York, United States
Rating: 4.6

Don Antonio's Pizza, 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019 · Pizza restaurant, Cocktail bar, Italian restaurant · 4.6/5 Google (2035 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout

Destination for Neapolitan pies with standout gluten-free options and some service rigidity; excellent pizzas on-site, delivery is inconsistent.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Don Antonio delivers excellent Neapolitan pizza with standout gluten-free options and impressive speed that makes it ideal for pre-theater dining in Midtown West. However, inconsistent delivery experiences and variable service attentiveness—particularly at the host stand—prevent a higher grade, while tight seating limits overall comfort. Strong core execution and loyal following position it as a competitive neighborhood favorite rather than a destination standout.

Restaurant Summary

Steps from the Broadway marquees, the room feels warm and bustling with pies flying from the oven and bar seats turning fast. Service is swift but can read brisk and procedural, especially at the host stand. As one diner put it, "Pizza landed fast and the crust had that perfect chew," while another warned, "delivery arrived cold and disappointing." Expect pre-show energy more than lingering calm. The cooking leans classic Neapolitan with flourishes—think stracciatella-topped specials, fried montanara, and pistachio-sausage pairings—elevated traditional rather than showy fusion. Margherita, Kesté, and the 10 Years Anniversary pie headline the raves, with many calling the gluten-free program exceptional. If you love soft-centered, tender-crusted pies, you will likely be thrilled; if you want brittle-crisp slices, temper expectations. Families do well here thanks to familiar pizza options and quick pacing. There is no noted kids menu, but simple Margherita, white pies, and Angioletti with Nutella suit younger palates. Gluten-free dough and even GF desserts are called out in reviews, making it a strong pick for mixed-diet groups. Space is tight, so strollers and large parties may find seating tricky at peak.

At a Glance

Excellent Neapolitan pies with standout gluten-free options
Fast pacing ideal for pre-theater dining
Rigid policy on substitutions and add-ons
Delivery quality inconsistent (cold, timing issues)
Bottled water is charged; drinks can feel pricey

What Sets It Apart

fried_pizza_specialties
robust_gluten_free_program
pre_theater_speed

What People Love

That tender Neapolitan chew and balanced sauce
Creative but grounded specials like the anniversary pie
Cozy, lively room with quick turnarounds
Reliable bar seating for solo or duo visits
Serious gluten-free execution beyond the norm

Points of Concern

Host stand can feel inflexible; limited willingness to modify pies
Delivery reports include cold food and incorrect timing
Seating is tight; some benches uncomfortable for longer meals
Review patterns show sharp polarization; dine-in raves vs. delivery/service lows

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$40-$58 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Start with arancini or crocchette, split a Regina Margherita, and share the 10 Years Anniversary pie.
For gluten-free diners, request GF versions of margherita or desserts; confirm availability before peak.
Kids often like Margherita or Bianca e Arugula; finish with Angioletti.

Perfect For

Pre-theater dinner with great pizza
Casual date at the bar
Gluten-free diners seeking true Neapolitan
Out-of-town friends near Times Square

Location Insights

Area: Busy Midtown West block near Broadway theaters; caters to pre/post-show diners and neighborhood crowds.

Safety: Well-trafficked, generally safe with strong evening footfall and active storefronts.

Nearby: Steps from Times Square and multiple theaters; hotels, bars, and 9th Ave dining corridor nearby.

Hell's KitchenHell's Kitchen is known for its diverse dining scene ranging from casual eateries to upscale restaurants. The neighborhood has a lively, urban atmosphere with a strong community feel, popular among locals and visitors seeking authentic and varied food options.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:30–22:00 Tuesday11:30–22:00 Wednesday11:30–22:00 Thursday11:30–22:00 Friday11:30–22:00 Saturday11:30–22:00 Sunday11:30–22:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →