Seemor
Fazio'sBWorth Trying
709 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (606 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood slice shop with standout grandma and Sicilian pizza, fair prices, and strong owner engagement, but mixed reports on counter service and delivery consistency.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Fazio's earns its grade through excellent pizza quality—particularly grandma and Sicilian slices with crisp crust and bright sauce—and genuine neighborhood appeal with loyal regulars and fair pricing. However, inconsistent execution and variable service politeness prevent higher standing, while the modest counter-and-stools setting lacks destination appeal. Best experienced fresh at the counter rather than via delivery.
Restaurant Summary
A classic Bushwick slice shop with warm neighborhood energy, Fazio's draws regulars for quick counter orders and a few tables to linger. One diner summed it up: "Grandma slice with a crisp bottom and bright sauce hit the spot." Owner responses feel genuinely engaged when things go wrong, and prices stay friendly for the area. The cooking skews traditional and comforting over trendy: Neapolitan, Sicilian, and grandma pies, plus calzones and arancini. Sauce sweetness and crust texture get the love, though delivery can sap that crisp edge. Best experience is fresh from the oven at the counter; if you are picky about texture, avoid long delivery runs and third-party apps. Families do well here thanks to kid-approved basics like plain slices, cheese calzones, and Italian ices ($3-$4). There is no kids menu, but simple orders work great. Vegan slices appear at times and veggie toppings are plentiful, though no gluten-free crust is listed.
At a Glance
- Grandma and Sicilian slices consistently praised for sauce and crust
- Fair neighborhood pricing with large, filling slices
- Delivery quality can be soggy or shifted; better eaten in-house
- Counter service politeness varies by staff and time
- Owner responds quickly and constructively to issues
What Sets It Apart
- excellent_grandma_slice
- authentic_sicilian_specialties
- strong_local_loyalty
What People Love
- Bright, balanced tomato sauce
- Crisp grandma crust
- Hearty calzones packed with cheese
- Feeling like a local at the counter
Points of Concern
- Delivery can arrive soggy or with topping slide, especially via third-party apps
- Several reports of curt or rude counter interactions
- Occasional overcooked or oversalted pies noted as off-nights
- Hours info can be inconsistent; verify before special trips
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$26 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Order Grandma or Sicilian fresh and eat on-site for best crust.
- If vegan, ask about dairy-free slices that day; otherwise build a veggie slice.
- Pair two slices and a drink for a filling budget meal under $15.
Perfect For
- A quick neighborhood slice stop
- Casual meet-up before bars
- Takeout night with a classic pie
- Solo counter meal while people-watching
Location Insights
Area: Creative, mixed-use Bushwick block with locals and newcomers; casual street energy and steady foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe for Brooklyn standards; lively during day and early evening, standard urban caution late.
Nearby: Near residential walk-ups, small shops, and bars; convenient for neighborhood slice stops and takeout.
BushwickBushwick is known for its vibrant street art, industrial-chic spaces, and a growing number of hip restaurants and bars. The dining scene is eclectic, featuring everything from authentic Latin American eateries to innovative fusion and contemporary cuisine. The neighborhood has a lively, artsy atmosphere attracting a mix of locals and newcomers seeking a creative and social environment.
Knickerbocker Avenue CorridorThis corridor along Knickerbocker Avenue blends residential and commercial spaces, with a mix of traditional Latin American establishments and newer trendy spots. It maintains a community-oriented feel while gradually embracing the neighborhood's evolving culinary and cultural trends.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–22:30
Tuesday11:30–22:30
Wednesday11:30–22:30
Thursday11:30–22:30
Friday11:30–23:30
Saturday11:30–23:30
Sunday11:30–22:30
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →