Seemor
Felice ColumbusB+Worth Trying
240 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
· Italian restaurant, Brunch restaurant, Caterer
· 4.5/5 Google (678 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Polished Upper West Side Italian with strong pastas, lively vibe, and fair value for NYC; service can be slow at peaks, so book early and pace expectations.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Felice Columbus delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining with excellent house-made pastas and seafood that justify its Upper West Side reputation. Consistency shows some quality variation, particularly during peak service when waits lengthen and execution occasionally falters, preventing the higher grade. The attractive chic bar and outdoor seating create an inviting pre-theater or date-night destination, though space comfort concerns and service speed inconsistencies keep it from grade A territory.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling with a chic bar and relaxed confidence. Guests describe service as "friendly and attentive" when the pace clicks, and several call out excellent pastas and seafood. One diner noted, "the pasta had that perfect bite," while another praised the salmon’s flaky texture and vibrant vegetables. The cooking leans elevated traditional Italian over trend-chasing, with house-made pasta, clean sauces, and well-sourced fish and steak. Think fettuccine bolognese that tastes rich but not heavy, branzino baked until just right, and reliable spritzes for a pre-show stop. It is a neighborhood staple feel rather than a destination for theatrics, ideal for those who value comforting flavors done well. Families do fine here thanks to familiar kid-friendly options like cacio e pepe, bolognese, burger and fries, and simple salads. Portions run generous on many pastas, and brunch brings omelets and French toast. There is no explicit kids menu, but the classics suit most young eaters; picky diners may want to steer toward simpler pasta or the burger.
At a Glance
- House-made pastas and branzino consistently praised
- Lively, stylish room ideal for dates and pre-theater
- Peak-time waits and occasional slow or uneven service
- Noise can spike during rush
- Clarify vegan needs; one mix-up reported
What Sets It Apart
- house_made_pasta_focus
- pre_theater_friendly_location
- polished_chic_bar
What People Love
- Rich yet balanced bolognese and lasagna
- Flaky, flavorful salmon and branzino
- Chic bar and relaxed neighborhood vibe
- Attentive servers who guide wine choices
Points of Concern
- Service pacing can lag at peak; expect waits even with reservations
- Noise levels can be high in the main room
- A few dishes arrive cooler than ideal or under-sauced
- Review patterns show isolated strong complaints; overall balance remains positive
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$58-78 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians, try Ravioli della Casa ($27) or Cacio e Pepe ($26)
- Seafood fans: Linguine Frutti di Mare ($34) or Branzino ($44)
- Value play: Pastas in the $25-28 range with generous portions
Perfect For
- Pre-theater dinner near Lincoln Center
- Casual date night with wine and pasta
- Family meals with classic Italian comfort
- Solo bar seating for a quick, quality pasta
Location Insights
Area: Affluent residential corridor near Lincoln Center, attracting theatergoers, families, and date nights.
Safety: Well-trafficked, generally safe with active evening foot traffic and good lighting.
Nearby: Close to Lincoln Center, American Museum of Natural History, and boutique retail on Columbus/Amsterdam.
Upper West SideThe Upper West Side boasts a diverse dining scene ranging from classic New York delis and casual cafes to upscale restaurants. The atmosphere is generally relaxed and family-friendly, with a strong emphasis on quality and variety, attracting both locals and tourists. The area is safe, walkable, and culturally rich, with many patrons enjoying pre- or post-dining visits to nearby theaters and museums.
Lincoln SquareLincoln Square is a sub-area within the Upper West Side centered around the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts. It has a sophisticated dining environment catering to visitors attending performances, with many upscale restaurants and bars. The vibe is cultured and somewhat upscale, blending residential calm with vibrant nightlife and arts-related activity.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–22:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:30
Thursday12:00–22:30
Friday12:00–22:30
Saturday11:00–22:30
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →