Solid late-night slice shop with wide variety and friendly staff; pizza quality polarizes from great to forgettable, wings disappoint, prices fair for the area.
La Citta Pizzeria delivers reliable neighborhood slice shop quality with warm, attentive staff and a bright, spacious setting that makes casual dining comfortable. However, inconsistent pizza execution—ranging from excellent vodka slices to underseasoned or dry cheese slices—and moderate review authenticity concerns create uncertainty about overall reliability. Worth visiting if nearby for convenient, reasonably-priced slices, but not a destination worth traveling for.
The room feels bright and spacious with plenty of tables for a slice shop, and staff are often called out as warm and polite. One diner put it simply: "Fast service and a clean, modern space made grabbing slices easy." However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. The cooking leans classic New York slice shop with a huge selection rather than chefly experiments. Favorites include the vodka and grandma slices, while some find the plain slice underseasoned or occasionally dry. Wings repeatedly disappoint, so stick to pies, calzones, and rolls for best results. Families fare well here: classic cheese and pepperoni, chicken fingers and fries, and customizable slices keep kids happy. Gluten-free and cauliflower crusts are available, though feedback on taste varies; if sensitivities are strict, verify before ordering.
Area vibe: Busy Third Ave corridor near Union Square/Gramercy; student and office foot traffic with late-night energy.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, active sidewalks into late hours; typical urban vigilance advised.
What's nearby: Near NYU, Union Square, offices, bars; steady daytime and late-night demand for quick meals.