Top-tier lobster rolls and quick, friendly counter service with premium prices for quality seafood; small space, occasional inconsistencies.
Luke's Lobster Union Square delivers excellent fresh lobster and chowder with genuinely friendly, knowledgeable counter service that elevates the casual experience. However, occasional quality dips—cold bread, soggy buns, inconsistent lobster texture—prevent grade A-level reliability, while the cramped seating and premium pricing limit broader appeal. It's a focused, ingredient-driven seafood shack that excels at its core mission but falls short of destination-restaurant distinction.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely expensive ($28-$39 lobster rolls; $8-$14 soups)