Seemor
Luke's Lobster Union SquareBWorth Trying
124 University Pl, New York, NY 10003
· Seafood restaurant, Caterer
· 4.5/5 Google (489 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Top-tier lobster rolls and quick, friendly counter service with premium prices for quality seafood; small space, occasional inconsistencies.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Luke's Lobster Union Square delivers excellent fresh lobster and chowder with genuinely friendly, knowledgeable counter service that elevates the casual experience. However, occasional quality dips—cold bread, soggy buns, inconsistent lobster texture—prevent grade A-level reliability, while the cramped seating and premium pricing limit broader appeal. It's a focused, ingredient-driven seafood shack that excels at its core mission but falls short of destination-restaurant distinction.
Restaurant Summary
This compact Union Square shack runs on friendly counter service, hot griddles, and a steady stream of lobster rolls. Reviewers talk about “chunky meat” and staff who explain the menu with patience, while noting the small seating area and quick turnover. One diner put it best: “the chowder was creamy and chunky, and the roll was buttered just right.” The cooking sticks to a Maine-style simplicity: chilled lobster kissed with lemon butter or a swipe of mayo, plus optional truffle or spicy honey butter. Flights make sampling easy, and soups like clam chowder and bisque draw consistent praise. It is not fancy; it is focused—quality seafood in a buttered bun—ideal for seafood fans who value ingredients over frills. For families, the menu is straightforward: lobster, crab, shrimp rolls with chips, and kid-pleasing lemonade. No kids menu, but simple sandwiches, soups, and sides work for many children. Space is tight, so strollers can be tricky; consider a quick stop or takeaway rather than a long sit-down.
At a Glance
- Fresh, generously packed lobster rolls with classic Maine flavors
- Friendly, informative counter team and fast service
- Seafood flights are a smart way to sample varieties
- Premium pricing; some guests feel portions are small for cost
- Occasional inconsistencies (cold bun, soggy roll, rubbery lobster)
What Sets It Apart
- seafood_roll_flights
- maine_style_focus
- loyalty_punch_card
What People Love
- The buttery, chunky lobster texture
- Classic Maine-style restraint that highlights seafood
- Soup pairings that are hearty and satisfying
- Helpful staff that guide choices and offer samples
Points of Concern
- Pricing is genuinely expensive ($28-$39 lobster rolls; $8-$14 soups)
- Space is small with limited seating; often best for quick visits
- Quality can vary at peak times (reports of soggy buns or cold bread appear occasionally)
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$38-$60 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose 6oz lobster roll if you want a fuller meal; 4oz plus soup works for lighter appetites
- Try spicy honey butter if truffle feels too rich
- Budget for tax and tip; combos like The Mainer maximize satisfaction
Perfect For
- Quick seafood lunch near Union Square
- Solo bites between classes or meetings
- Out-of-towners chasing iconic lobster rolls
- Takeaway before a park stroll
Location Insights
Area: Energetic, student-and-office mix near Union Square; steady foot traffic and casual dining focus.
Safety: Generally safe, busy corridors with good lighting; standard urban cleanliness variations.
Nearby: Near NYU, Union Square Park, shops, and transit; high lunchtime flow and tourist spillover.
East VillageThe East Village is known for its eclectic dining scene ranging from casual eateries to trendy restaurants and bars. It has a lively, youthful atmosphere with a strong emphasis on creativity and alternative culture, attracting a crowd interested in unique culinary experiences and nightlife.
Stuyvesant Square AreaThis micro-neighborhood near Stuyvesant Square Park is quieter and more residential compared to the busier parts of the East Village, featuring a mix of historic brownstones and small local businesses. Dining here tends to be more relaxed with neighborhood-focused cafes and bistros.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–20:00
Tuesday11:00–20:00
Wednesday11:00–20:00
Thursday11:00–20:00
Friday11:00–20:00
Saturday11:00–20:00
Sunday11:00–19:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →