Stylish SoHo spot with standout cocktails, good pizza and shareables, lively vibe, and occasionally inconsistent food and service; best for drinks-plus-bites rather than a precision fine-dining meal.
Odd Sister delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional setting appeal and strong service execution that create a warm, buzzing atmosphere ideal for groups and celebrations. However, inconsistent food execution—with reports of salty or flat seasoning across brunch and dinner—prevents the kitchen from matching the room's polish. Cocktails and pizzas are reliable crowd-pleasers, making this a worthwhile SoHo destination for casual dining and drinks rather than destination-level cuisine.
One caveat: Seasoning inconsistency noted across multiple visits (too salty or under-seasoned)